- 1931 Henry Ciuci
- 1932 Johnny Golden
- 1933 Johnny Golden
- 1934 Johnny Golden
- 1935 Johnny Golden
- 1936 Leo Mallory
- 1937 Leo Mallory
- 1938 Edward Burke
- 1939 Harry Cooper
- 1940 Harold H. Mandly, Jr.
- 1941 Jimmy Demaret
- 1942 Geen toernooi wegens WO II
- 1943 Geen toernooi wegens WO II
- 1944 Geen toernooi wegens WO II
- 1945 Geen toernooi wegens WO II
- 1946 Felice Torza
- 1947 Frank Strazza
- 1948 Frank Staszowski
- 1949 Frank Staszowski
- 1950 Harry Nettelbladt
| - 1951 Harry Nettelbladt
- 1952 J. Curtin
- 1953 L. Brownlee
- 1954 Ted Lenczyk
- 1955 J. Galeski
- 1956 Donald Hoenig
- 1957 Donald Hoenig
- 1958 Dick Siderowf
- 1959 Dick Siderowf
- 1960 Allan Breed
- 1961 Eddie Kuna
- 1962 Bob Cloughen
- 1963 John Cleary
- 1964 Bob Kay
- 1965 Jerry Courville
- 1966 Roy Pace
- 1967 Roy Pace
- 1968 Denny Lyons
- 1969 Mike Ballo
- 1970 John Gentile
| - 1971 Robert Benson
- 1972 Paul Kelly
- 1973 Dick Siderowf
- 1974 Austin Straub
- 1975 James Becker
- 1976 James Becker
- 1977 Robert Benson
- 1978 Mike Ballo
- 1979 Doug Dalziel
- 1980 Doug Dalziel
- 1981 Ed Sabo
- 1982 Ed Sabo
- 1983 Ed Sabo
- 1984 Jack McConachie
- 1985 Ken Green
- 1986 Mike Colandro
- 1987 Kevin Giancola
- 1988 Kevin Giancola
- 1989 John Parsons
- 1990 Michael Downey
| - 1991 Mike Colandro
- 1992 Ken Green
- 1993 Michael Gilmore
- 1994 Kevin Giancola
- 1995 John Gentile
- 1996 Brendan Walsh
- 1997 Michael Gilmore
- 1998 Kyle Gallo
- 1999 Jay Rice
- 2000 Kyle Gallo
- 2001 John Paesani
- 2002 James St. Pierre
- 2003 Steve Sokol
- 2004 Kyle Gallo
- 2005 Nick Cook
- 2006 Nick Cook
- 2007 Jeff Curl
- 2008 Jeff Hedden
- 2009 Frank Bensel
- 2010 Kyle Gallo
| - 2011 Frank Bensel
- 2012 Jason Caron
- 2013 Jeff Curl
|