- 1903: Myra D. Paterson
- 1904: Myra D. Paterson
- 1905: Houghton Dutton
- 1906: Myra D. Paterson
- 1907: Molly B. Adams
- 1908: Julia R. Mix
- 1909: Mary Fownes
- 1910: Florence Vanderbeck
- 1911: Louise Elkins
- 1912: Mrs. J. Raymond Price
- 1913: Lillian B. Hyde
- 1914: Florence L. Harvey
- 1915: Nonna Barlow
- 1916: Nonna Barlow
- 1917: Elaine Rosenthal
- 1918: Dorothy Campbell
- 1919: Nonna Barlow
- 1920: Dorothy Campbell
- 1921: Dorothy Campbell
- 1922: Glenna Collett
- 1923: Glenna Collett
- 1924: Glenna Collett
- 1925: Mrs. Melville Jones
- 1926: Louise Fordyce
- 1927: Glenna Collett
- 1928: Opal Hill
- 1929: Glenna Collett
- 1930: Glenna Collett
- 1931: Maureen Orcutt
- 1932: Maureen Orcutt
- 1933: Maureen Orcutt
| - 1934: Charlotte Glutting
- 1935: Estelle Lawson
- 1936: Deborah Verry
- 1937: Estelle Lawson Page
- 1938: Jane Cothran
- 1939: Estelle Lawson Page
- 1940: Estelle Lawson Page
- 1941: Estelle Lawson Page
- 1942: Louise Suggs
- 1943: Dorothy Kirby
- 1944: Estelle Lawson Page
- 1945: Estelle Lawson Page
- 1946: Louise Suggs
- 1947: Babe Zaharias
- 1948: Louise Suggs
- 1949: Peggy Kirk
- 1950: Pat O'Sullivan
- 1951: Pat O'Sullivan
- 1952: Barbara Romack
- 1953: Pat O'Sullivan
- 1954: Joyce Ziske
- 1955: Wiffi Smith
- 1956: Marlene Stewart
- 1957: Barbara McIntire
- 1958: Carolyn Cudone
- 1959: Ann Casey Johnstone
- 1960: Barbara McIntire
- 1961: Barbara McIntire
- 1962: Clifford Ann Creed
- 1963: Nancy Roth
- 1964: Phyllis Preuss
| - 1965: Barbara McIntire
- 1966: Nancy Roth Syms
- 1967: Phyllis Preuss
- 1968: Alice Dye
- 1969: Barbara McIntire
- 1970: Hollis Stacy
- 1971: Barbara McIntire
- 1972: Jane Booth [1]
- 1973: Beth Barry
- 1974: Marlene Stewart
- 1975: Cynthia Hill
- 1976: Carol Semple
- 1977: Marcia Dolan
- 1978: Cathy Sherk
- 1979: Julie Gumlia
- 1980: Charlotte Montgomery
- 1981: Patti Rizzo
- 1982: Anne Quast Sander
- 1983: Anne Quast Sander
- 1984: Susan Pager
- 1985: LeeAnn Hammack [2]
- 1986: Leslie Shannon
- 1987: Carol Semple Thompson
- 1988: Donna Andrews
- 1989: Page Marsh
- 1990: Brandie Burton
- 1991: Kelly Robbins
- 1992: Stephanie Sparks
- 1993: Emilee Klein
- 1994: Stephanie Neill
- 1995: Laura Philo
| - 1996: Kristen Samp
- 1997: Kerry Postillon [3]
- 1998: Beth Bauer
- 1999: Beth Bauer
- 2000: Candy Hannemann
- 2001: Meredith Duncan
- 2002: May Wood
- 2003: Brittany Lang
- 2004: Morgan Pressel
- 2005: Yani Tseng
- 2006: Jenny Suh
- 2007: Alison Walshe
- 2008: Kristie Smith
- 2009: Amelia Lewis [4]
- 2010: Cydney Clanton
- 2011: Danielle Kang
- 2012: Austin Ernst
- 2013: Ally McDonald
- 2014: Alison Lee
- 2015: Bailey Tardy
- 2016: Kristen Gillman
- 2017: Isabella Fierro
- 2018: Stephanie Lau
- 2019: Gabriela Ruffels
- 2020: Rachel Kuehn
- 2021: Gina Kim
- 2022: Emilia Migliaccio
- 2023: Anna Morgan
|